Best Automatic Cat Feeder for Multiple Cats — 5 Models Compared

What matters for a multi-cat feeder

• Portion accuracy — the feeder must dispense the same amount every time, even with different kibble sizes. Inconsistent portions lead to one cat gaining weight while the other loses it.
• Food capacity — a multi-cat household burns through kibble faster. Look for at least 6-cup capacity if you're feeding 2 cats, 10+ cups for 3+ cats.
• Mechanism reliability — the most common failure is the rotating tray or paddle jamming on irregularly shaped kibble. Stick feeders (flat trays with lids) have fewer moving parts.
• Lid security — clever cats will pry open flimsy lids. The best models use locking mechanisms or heavy-duty clips.
• Ease of cleaning — multi-cat feeders get dirty fast. Dishwasher-safe bowls and removable trays save time.
• Power options — battery backup matters if your power flickers. A feeder that stops mid-cycle because the outlet tripped defeats the purpose.

Top picks at a glance

1. PetSafe 5-Meal Automatic Pet Feeder — Best overall for 2-Cat Mate C500 Digital 5-Meal Pet Feeder households (~$49.95)

The PetSafe 5-Meal holds a 4.4-star rating from over 12,847 verified Amazon reviews. At $49.95, it sits in the mid-range tier. The rotating tray design dispenses up to 5 pre-portioned meals, each holding roughly 1 cup of dry food. For a 2-cat household, you can load enough food for a full day with two meals per cat. The tray is dishwasher-safe, and the unit runs on 4 D-cell batteries (not included), which means it keeps working during power outages. The lid locks with a simple twist mechanism that most cats haven't figured out.

Common complaints owners report: the 1-cup portion size isn't adjustable, so if your cats need smaller meals you'll have to underfill the tray slots manually. A small share of owners report the tray sometimes advances too early, dispensing a meal before the scheduled time. The unit also lacks WiFi, so there's no way to check if a meal was dispensed while you're away.

2. PetSafe Eatwell 2-Meal Training Feeder — Budget pick for scheduled meals (~$24.95)

The PetSafe Eatwell 2-Meal holds a 4.3-star rating from over 8,234 verified Amazon reviews. At $24.95, it's the most affordable option in this roundup. This feeder has just two compartments, each holding about 1.5 cups. It's designed for cats who need two fixed meals per day — morning and evening. The timer is mechanical (no WiFi or digital display), which means it's reliable but not programmable beyond setting two time delays. For a 2-cat household where both cats eat the same amount at the same time, this is the simplest solution.

Common complaints owners report: the mechanical timer can drift by 15-30 minutes over a week, which matters if your cats are on a strict medication schedule. The lid doesn't lock, so persistent cats can pry it open. Some owners report the tray lid gets stuck if kibble is pushed against it.

3. Petlibro Granary Automatic Pet Feeder — Best for WiFi control (~$49.99)

The Petlibro Granary holds a 4.4-star rating from over 15,623 verified Amazon reviews. At $49.99, it competes directly with the PetSafe 5-Meal. The Petlibro adds WiFi connectivity and a companion app that lets you schedule meals remotely, adjust portion sizes, and get feeding notifications. For multi-cat households where one cat needs more food than the other, the app's individual portion control is the key differentiator. The 5L capacity (roughly 20 cups) handles 2-3 cats for several days.

Common complaints owners report: the WiFi connection drops intermittently, especially on 2.4GHz networks crowded with smart home devices. Several owners report the feeder's clock drifts over time, requiring manual reset every 2-3 weeks. The app interface is clunky and sometimes fails to sync the feeding schedule to the device.

4. Cat Mate C500 Digital 5-Meal Pet Feeder — Best for portion accuracy (~$69.99)

The Cat Mate C500 holds a 4.1-star rating from over 3,421 verified Amazon reviews. At $69.99, it's the priciest option here, but it earns that premium with precise digital timing and a sealed ice-pack compartment that keeps wet food fresh for up to 48 hours. The five compartments each hold about 5.5 oz, which is enough for a small-to-medium cat's meal. For households where one cat eats wet food and the other eats dry, the C500's sealed compartments are the only option that handles both without spoiling.

Common complaints owners report: the ice packs need to be frozen overnight, which adds a step to your routine. The compartment lids are flimsy and some cats learn to flip them open. The digital display is hard to read in low light, making programming frustrating.

5. WOpet Automatic Cat Feeder with WiFi — Best value with camera (~$39.99)

The WOpet holds a 4.3-star rating from over 8,912 verified Amazon reviews. At $39.99, it's the cheapest WiFi-connected option in this roundup. The built-in camera lets you check on your cats remotely, and the app lets you schedule up to 6 meals per day with adjustable portions. The 4L capacity (about 16 cups) handles 2 cats for 2-3 days. The voice recording feature lets you call your cats to meals, which helps if one cat eats in a different room.

Common complaints owners report: the camera quality is poor in low light, making it hard to see which cat is eating. The WiFi setup process is confusing and several owners report the feeder losing its connection after firmware updates. The kibble hopper is narrow, so larger kibble pieces sometimes jam the dispensing mechanism.

Bottom line

For most 2-cat households, the PetSafe 5-Meal ($49.95, 12,847 reviews, 4.4 stars) is the safest pick — its rotating tray is reliable, the lid locks, and battery power means it works through outages. If you need WiFi scheduling and portion control for cats on different diets, the Petlibro Granary ($49.99, 15,623 reviews, 4.4 stars) offers the best app experience despite occasional WiFi drops. For wet-food households, the Cat Mate C500 ($69.99, 3,421 reviews, 4.1 stars) is the only model with sealed compartments that actually keep wet food fresh.